Skip to content
Skip to product information
115 Reviews

Vanilla Heart Mix

$12.00
Arrives After Father's Day

Arrives After Father's Day

Vanilla Heart Mix
New product
$12.00
Each tube is filled with 10oz of Taffy Add a personal gift note in checkout Optional future delivery in checkout Arrives fast & fresh
Description:
Our Very Vanilla taffy received an upgrade! This heart mix features an assortment of vanilla salt water taffy with different heart shapes handmade in the taffy!  It’s a batch made...

Our Very Vanilla taffy received an upgrade! This heart mix features an assortment of vanilla salt water taffy with different heart shapes handmade in the taffy!  It’s a batch made in heaven! 

Corn Syrup, Sugar, Palm Oil, Egg White, Natural and Artificial Flavor, Soy Lecithin as an emulsifier, Added Color (Red 40, Red 3, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Blue 1)
Contains: Egg, Soy (lecithin)

Join The G.O.A.T. Club

Receive exclusive perks that can be used across our entire family of stores (a total of 8 right now)!

Now only $9.95 per year

Free Shipping On Every Order
Members-Only Monthly Deals
Early Access To New Product Releases
First Dibs On New Brands We Launch

Overall rating: 4.3006535 / 5 from 153 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Vanilla Heart Mix offers a delightful assortment of vanilla salt water taffy with handmade heart shapes. While the vanilla flavor is praised for its classic taste, some customers find the overall flavor varied and not always authentic.

Summary topics

  • Vanilla Quality: 7%
  • Flavor Profile: 47%

Review topics: [flavor, quality, shipping, order, packaging, gift, vanilla, taffy, texture, tube, banana].

Review highlights

  • "Excellent texture and flavor"John A.
  • "Excellent flavours, all 3 tubes were decadent."D H.
  • "Amazing taste, Quick Delivery."Brenda

Reviews

A bit disappointed with this

"A bit disappointed with this one, just has a bit of a weird taste to it, almost metallic! Good vanilla initially but weird aftertaste. But all 5 other flavor tubes were absolutely fantastic!"

Shirley H. (4/5)

Taffy seems old. Paper stuck

"Taffy seems old. Paper stuck to candy in many cases threw it out because you couldn’t get it off"

Susan L. (2/5)

"Loved this flavor. Tasted newly made and great flavr."

michele (5/5)

"The sunflower seeds arrived Christmas Eve. When I opened the box, it was just packets and packets of sunflower seeds all in one big box loose I had ordered three matching sets. This is ridiculous are still sitting in the box or loose and they’re very dry to eat. I completely regret this purchase. $150. !!"

Kim (2/5)

The taffy 'Very Vanilla" is

"The taffy 'Very Vanilla" is absolutely delightful. The vanilla is smooth, creamy, and full of that classic old-fashioned flavor. ' '"

Flora S. (5/5)

Not as good as I've come to expect

"I have bought the very vanilla taffy many times and it's always delicious. I bought 2 containers of it as Christmas gifts and there was no taste at all for me or the recipient. Maybe someone forgot to add in the flavoring?"

Sue (3/5)

Loved it vanilla is my

"Loved it vanilla is my favorite"

Brian B. (5/5)

Did not like them.

"Did not like them."

Debbie A. (1/5)

I was hoping for a

"I was hoping for a vanilla bean taste. But these are good"

Carrie M. (3/5)

Had a processed taste

"Had a processed taste"

Patrick M. (4/5)

Q&A