Our Very Vanilla taffy received an upgrade! This heart mix features an assortment of vanilla salt water taffy with different heart shapes handmade in the taffy! It’s a batch made in heaven!
Receive exclusive perks that can be used across our entire family of stores (a total of 8 right now)!
Now only $9.95 per year
Overall rating: 4.2375 / 5 from 160 reviews.
The Vanilla Heart Mix offers a delightful assortment of vanilla salt water taffy with handmade heart shapes. While the vanilla flavor is praised for its classic taste, some customers find the overall flavor varied and not always authentic.
Review topics: [flavor, quality, shipping, order, packaging, vanilla, texture, taffy, gift, tube, banana].
"These were ok. Some were normal texture of taffy and were good while others were so melted they had to be thrown out, you couldn't even get them off the paper. I find the difference in one container not very hopeful for the rest of them."
"I had this Taffy while visiting a friend and fell in love with it. It was so soft and melted in your mouth. I was so excited to send it to my mom for Mother’s Day. I was so disappointed. Taffy was so hard you couldn’t even bite into it. Only option was to apologize, buy her something else and throw it away."
"Kind of bland and the wrapper’s a were melted to the taffy"
"I bought the vanilla, coconut cream, and triple chocolate. Was disappointed in the graininess of the vanilla and coconut cream. They should be soother - especially for the price. Also, the candies are not individually labeled - coconut cream and vanilla look exactly the same ."
"Your taffy has been getting worse used to love, I wouldn’t gift these to anybody"
"Love the vanilla…. delicious!!!!"
"Best vanilla Taffy ever"
"A bit disappointed with this one, just has a bit of a weird taste to it, almost metallic! Good vanilla initially but weird aftertaste. But all 5 other flavor tubes were absolutely fantastic!"
"Taffy seems old. Paper stuck to candy in many cases threw it out because you couldn’t get it off"
"Loved this flavor. Tasted newly made and great flavr."
