Skip to content

Arrives Fast & Fresh

40+ Flavors To Choose From

About Us Help
Skip to product information
360 Reviews

Old Fashioned Banana Split Sampler Gift Box

$48.00

MAKE IT A SPECIAL OCCASION

gift band image
ADD A GIFT BAND
$3.00

What's included

6 tubes · 6 oz per tube

  • Fresh Strawberry

    Fresh Strawberry

  • Banana Bonanza

    Banana Bonanza

  • Chocolate Fudge

    Chocolate Fudge

  • Very Vanilla

    Very Vanilla

  • Pineapple Fusion

    Pineapple Fusion

  • Cherry Bomb

    Cherry Bomb

Old Fashioned Banana Split Sampler Gift Box
New product
$48.00

MAKE IT A SPECIAL OCCASION

gift band image
ADD A GIFT BAND
$3.00
Each tube is filled with 6oz of Taffy Add a personal gift note in checkout Optional future delivery in checkout Arrives fast & fresh
Description:
Introducing our Old Fashioned Banana Split Sampler Gift Box, a nostalgic selection that brings the classic dessert experience to your doorstep. Each flavor is carefully crafted to capture the essence...

Introducing our Old Fashioned Banana Split Sampler Gift Box, a nostalgic selection that brings the classic dessert experience to your doorstep. Each flavor is carefully crafted to capture the essence of this iconic treat, offering a symphony of indulgent tastes and textures. 

Includes 6 tubes - approx 5 oz each - with elevated Gift Box packaging.

  • Fresh Strawberry
  • Banana Bonanza
  • Chocolate Fudge
  • Very Vanilla
  • Pineapple Fusion
  • Cherry Bomb

You May Also Like

Join The G.O.A.T. Club

Receive exclusive perks that can be used across our entire family of stores (a total of 8 right now)!

Now only $9.95 per year

Free Shipping On Every Order
Members-Only Monthly Deals
Early Access To New Product Releases
First Dibs On New Brands We Launch

Overall rating: 4.7348065 / 5 from 362 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Old Fashioned Banana Split Sampler Gift Box offers a nostalgic selection of six carefully crafted flavors, each praised for its fresh and flavorful taste. Customers appreciate the variety and deliciousness of the sampler, making it a delightful gift choice.

Summary topics

  • Banana Flavor (9%): Customers expressed appreciation for the fresh and flavorful taste of the banana in the gift box.
  • Flavor Variety (62%): Many customers raved about the great flavor, with multiple reviews mentioning it as wonderful or fabulous.

Review topics: ["flavor","shipping","packaging","order","favorite","consistency","texture","taffy","vanilla","banana","candy","pieces","containers","tube"].

Review highlights

  • "Great taste and the texture is not too sticky." — David B.
  • "Absolutely delicious tastes just like the fair taffy I loved as a kid!" — Gail W.
  • "I love Banana tasting taffy , and this had a lot of flavor." — Mechele S.

Reviews

"That Taffy was the Bomb !!! Weeeeee I shared some with my sister not many because I Loved it I won't say how long it took me to EAT IT ALL .THIS WOULD HAVE BEEN THE SECOND WEEK ITS ALL GONE , I WILL BE PLACING ANOTHER ORDER FOR SURE !!! YOU CAN'T BEET WHAT I EAT !!!🍭🍭🍭"

— Joanne (5/5)

The flavor of the taffy

"The flavor of the taffy was delicious, but they are so sticky! Every time I opened one (with the exception of the banana flavor) I had to scrub taffy off my fingers. If that could be rectified, they would be great."

— Jackie K. (3/5)

"The taffy sticks to the wrapper and is hard to peel off without sticking to your fingers. It seems like it was exposed to heat during shipping."

— William (4/5)

Absolutely love this flavor. You

"Absolutely love this flavor. You were out of it for a while and I was beginning to panic! Glad you got it back in stock. It's my treat to myself!"

— Beverly K. (5/5)

"Salt wayer taffy is one of my favorite snacks. I like the different flavors...especially the banana and watermelon."

— Michael (5/5)

"Love the taste DISLIKE THE WRAPPER WAS VERY HARD TO RELEASE THE CARMEL?"

— Angie (5/5)

Great Flavor - Melty Delivery

"I recently purchased taffy from Taffy. com at the airport and was so excited when I came across it because taffy is my absolute favorite candy! Unfortunately, I was a little disappointed when I opened the package. Due to the heat, all of the pieces had melted together into one large chunk, and I wasn’t able to separate them individually. That said, I still think the taffy itself is fantastic and would definitely consider purchasing it again—especially online, where I’m hoping it would arrive in better condition. My absolute favorites are all of the fruit/candy flavors! 🍓🍊🍉🍇 Hopefully, there’s a way to prevent the candy from melting during warmer months, because the product is too good not to enjoy the way it’s intended! 💕"

— Lee J. (3/5)

Addictive! Taffy, just the way

"Addictive! Taffy, just the way I crave it."

— Stephen C. (5/5)

"taffy was stuck to the wrapper on a few of them"

— Denise (2/5)

"Delicious!"

— Pam (5/5)

Q&A